Blog

The Double-Three Rule in Gomoku: What Exactly Is Forbidden?

Published

Contents
  1. Why double-three is forbidden
  2. The classic double-three
  3. A split three is an open three too
  4. When two lines of three are allowed
  5. Summary
  6. Making the rule work for you

The first time someone tells you “you can’t play there, that’s a double-three,” it feels unfair. It was obviously a good move. And then, in another game, you make two lines of three and it is perfectly legal. The confusion comes from one fact: the rule does not count “three stones.” It counts open threes.

This article follows the Korean standard rules used in most Korean online Omok, where double-three is forbidden for both Black and White.

In the diagrams, ● is your stone, ○ is your opponent’s, · is an empty point, and × is the point you want to play.

Why double-three is forbidden

Start with a “four”: four stones that become five with one more move. A four with both ends empty is called an open four.

· ● ● ● ● ·

An open four makes five on the left or on the right. Your opponent can block only one side per move, so unless they can make five first, an open four wins the game.

An open three is three stones that become an open four with one more move.

· · ● ● ● · ·

That is why an open three has to be blocked right away. Now suppose you make two open threes at once. Your opponent can block only one. The other becomes an open four. There is no defense.

Because the player who moves first could create this too easily, the double-three rule forbids it to keep the game fair.

The classic double-three

· · · ● · · ·
· · · ● · · ·
· ● ● × · · ·
· · · · · · ·

Playing × makes an open three horizontally and an open three vertically at the same time. It is forbidden.

A split three is an open three too

The three stones do not have to be touching.

· ● ● · ● ·

One move in the gap makes an open four, so this counts as an open three. One solid three plus one split three, made in a single move, is still a double-three.

When two lines of three are allowed

This is the key part. In the following cases the move is legal.

1. A blocked three does not count

○ ● ● × · ·

The left end is blocked by an enemy stone. One more move cannot make an open four, so this is not an open three. A three against the edge of the board is the same. A move that makes one open three and one blocked three is not forbidden.

2. A four-three is not forbidden

Making one four and one open three in a single move is allowed. Only two open threes are forbidden. The four-three is the most reliable attack in the game.

3. A double-four is allowed

Under the Korean standard rules you may also make two fours at once. (Under Renju rules this is forbidden for Black.)

4. Completing five is never forbidden

If the move completes exactly five in a row, you may play it and you win, even if it also creates a double-three.

Summary

What one move creates Allowed?
Open three + open three ✕ Forbidden
Open three + blocked three Yes
Four + open three (four-three) Yes
Four + four (double-four) Yes
Five in a row (even with a double-three) Yes, and it wins

Making the rule work for you

Under these rules, your opponent cannot play a double-three either. You can use that in defense. If the point your opponent badly needs happens to be a double-three for them, they cannot play it.

In Gomoku on Gamengager, forbidden points are marked with ✕ on your turn. Look at a marked point, find the two open threes that make it forbidden, and the rule soon becomes easy to see.

One note on how the rule is judged here. This site checks only whether one more move would make an open four. It does not go on to check whether that further point is itself forbidden. This is simpler than the detailed judging used in Renju.

Sources

Play this game: Gomoku (Omok)

Related posts