Blog

The Game the First Player Wins: Why Gomoku Has Forbidden Moves

Published

Contents
  1. A game of lining up five
  2. The problem: the first player wins
  3. The first answer: tie Black’s hands. Renju.
  4. The second answer: make the opening fair
  5. The Korean answer: no double-three for either side
  6. Side by side
  7. Forbidden moves are balance, not a nuisance

The rules of Gomoku fit in one line: the first to line up five stones wins. Yet when you actually play, conditions appear. “No double-three.” “Six in a row doesn’t count.” Why does such a simple game have forbidden moves?

There is one reason. Without restrictions, the player who moves first has far too great an advantage.

A game of lining up five

Gomoku took shape in Japan. It dates to the mid-1700s, in the Edo period, and by around 1850 it had spread widely among ordinary people. The earliest book that can be verified is a collection of standard sequences published in 1856.

The Japanese name is gomokunarabe (五目並べ): lining up (narabe) five (go) pieces (moku). The Korean name omok comes from the same characters, 五目.

In the 19th century the game reached Britain, where it was called “Go Bang,” from goban, the Japanese word for a Go board.

The problem: the first player wins

People who played a lot noticed it early. If Black, moving first, simply keeps attacking, White spends the whole game blocking and then loses.

This is not just a feeling. In 1994 the Dutch computer scientist L. Victor Allis proved that in unrestricted Gomoku on a 15×15 board, the first player has a winning strategy. If both sides play perfectly, the result is already decided by who makes the first move.

A game whose winner is fixed in advance is not much of a contest. So the history of Gomoku became the history of one question: how do you take away the first player’s edge?

The first answer: tie Black’s hands. Renju.

The first answer to take hold was to restrict Black alone.

On December 6, 1899, the Japanese journalist Kuroiwa Ruikō gave the game the name renju (連珠), “connected pearls,” in his newspaper Yorozu Chōhō. Renju went on to be refined into a competitive game with rules that cut down Black’s advantage.

Under Renju rules, Black may not play three kinds of move.

Forbidden move Meaning
Double-three One move that makes two open threes
Double-four One move that makes two fours
Overline A line of six or more

White has no restrictions at all. In fact White wins with six or more in a row, and White also wins by forcing Black into a position where the only move is a forbidden one. Black’s forbidden moves become White’s weapon.

On August 8, 1988, the Renju International Federation (RIF) was founded in Stockholm, Sweden, and Renju became an international sport.

The second answer: make the opening fair

Forbidden moves were not enough. Black was still ahead. So Renju began to change how the first few moves are made.

One player places the opening stones, and the other then chooses whether to play Black or White. If the shape you lay down favors one side too much, your opponent simply takes that side, so you have to lay down something balanced. It is the same idea as having one person cut the cake and the other choose the slice.

These opening rules have kept changing. The RIF opening rule arrived in 1997, and new rules were introduced in 2009, 2017 and 2024.

World championships in Gomoku without forbidden moves went the same way. Since 2009 they have used an opening rule called Swap2, which brings the first player’s winning rate to around 52%.

The Korean answer: no double-three for either side

The approach common in Korea is a little different. It is usually called the standard rules.

  • Double-three is forbidden for both Black and White.
  • Double-four is allowed.
  • Six or more in a row does not count as a win.

Instead of tying only Black’s hands, it puts the same limits on both players. The rules do not lean to one side, so they are easy to learn and work with any opponent straight away. Gomoku on Gamengager follows these rules.

Side by side

Rules Double-three Double-four Six or more Notes
Free-style Allowed Allowed Wins The first player can always win
Renju Forbidden for Black only Forbidden for Black only Forbidden for Black, wins for White International competition rules, used with opening rules
Korean standard Forbidden for both Allowed Does not win Same limits for both sides

Forbidden moves are balance, not a nuisance

At first the forbidden moves feel like an annoying restriction. But without them, Gomoku is a game the first player wins. Because of them, the second player has a chance too, and there is a real contest.

Finding the four-three when the double-three is closed to you. Using your opponent’s forbidden points in your own defense. The depth of the game comes from exactly these limits.

Sources

Play this game: Gomoku (Omok)

Related posts